Dissecting Differences: Staff Augmentation vs. BPO
In a changing business world, companies use BPO and staff augmentation to enhance productivity and save costs. While both involve third-party professionals, they differ significantly. Learn how to choose the right model for your needs in this article.
Get our quarterly newsletter
How-to guides, industry updates, tips and actionable advice on how to manage your BPO team like a pro.
Table of Contents
Amid the rapidly evolving business landscape, companies seek various options to boost their operations without draining their budget. Two cost-effective models serve as their keys to achieving that: business process outsourcing (BPO) and staff augmentation.
Both approaches involve working with third-party professionals to enhance productivity and cut expenses. Although people often use staff augmentation and BPO synonymously, these solutions have significant differences that organizations need to understand in order to optimize each strategy more effectively.
This article can help you decide which model best suits your business needs and project requirements. Keep reading!
Critical variations between staff augmentation and BPO
Delegating an entire function to a third-party company is what BPO is. Service providers manage a part or the whole of your back- and front-office processes, letting your in-house team prioritize core competencies and efforts.
Many businesses thus rely on outsourcing to gain such benefits. Grand View Research reported that the global BPO industry achieved $280.64 billion in 2023 and is set to expand at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of more than 9% by 2030. Enhanced flexibility, increased savings, and improved quality drive the growth.
Meanwhile, staff augmentation is a type of outsourcing that involves hiring temporary personnel to fill skill gaps for specific projects. Businesses hire augmented staff to help complete tasks quickly instead of entrusting them with a whole program cycle.
These basic definitions might give you a sense that these outsourcing models are just two sides of the same coin. However, a closer examination reveals their distinct characteristics, implications, and use cases for your company.
The table below lets us explore the differences between staff augmentation and BPO.
Staff Augmentation
Factor
BPO
The pricing is based on the number of hours or days the augmented team members work.
The service rates vary depending on factors such as skill level, professional experience, and project complexity.
Hiring third-party personnel from a staff augmentation agency might incur expenses related to job advertising, candidate outsourcing, and onboarding.
In cases where augmented employees need to travel for on-site work, clients may have to cover travel and accommodation costs.
Cost structure
The cost structure is fixed or variable, depending on contract terms and conditions.
Clients can pay service fees monthly, hourly, or via subscriptions.
Transitioning the outsourced functions to the BPO provider might involve initial setup costs.
Some outsourcing arrangements include pricing based on the volume of work and the number of transactions.
BPO companies invest in information technology (IT) systems to support outsourced processes. These costs, such as software license fees, might be part of the service charge.
Short-term engagements last from a few weeks to a few months.
Long-term contracts extend from several months to a year or more.
Open-ended agreements have no predefined expiration date but can be terminated or modified with adequate notice.
Project-based arrangements follow a particular task’s due dates.
Contract duration
Short-term contracts span from a few months to a year.
Long-term deals last multiple years due to the need to sustain and continue essential functions.
Renewable contracts extend an initial agreement for a certain period based on fluctuating business needs and outcomes.
Project-based engagements run according to a specific initiative’s timeline.
Staff augmentation services are limited and more specialized.
Augmented workers perform specific tasks.
For example, a client organization hires three third-party developers to support its software development effort.
Scope
Outsourcing encompasses all tasks of a business function.
For instance, the IT support company provides managed services, including network management, system maintenance, and security monitoring.
The BPO firm takes over the project management cycle, from planning to legal compliance.
The client manages the staff augmentation project.
In-house project managers monitor the progress of third-party personnel’s tasks.
Process control
The third-party service provider oversees the entire front- or back-office process.
The BPO project leaders track their team members’ performance and output.
Clients can directly select individuals with specific skills and domain knowledge to match their unique requirements.
The augmented workforce can include freelancers or full-time employees from a staffing agency.
Skill access
Service providers employ and maintain specialized units with expertise in different fields.
Clients can access a large talent pool with diverse skills and work experience.
Clients brief the augmented unit on their processes, systems, and project goals.
The onboarding process involves orientation sessions, project reviews, and introductory meetings with key stakeholders.
Training in the staff augmentation model includes integration activities to build rapport and facilitate knowledge sharing between internal and external members.
Training
BPO training prioritizes familiarity with a client’s products, services, and procedures. This knowledge is required to deliver outsourced services.
Service vendors implement standardized training and workforce engagement programs for their full-time workers.
BPO companies use advanced training tools and resources to accommodate large volumes of new hires or rapid expansions.
Clients integrate augmented staff directly into their existing IT and enterprise systems.
Freelancers or independent contractors use their own equipment to complete tasks remotely.
Technology usage and integration
BPO companies operate using their proprietary tech infrastructure.
BPO clients have limited control over systems used in service delivery. The provider dictates the tech stack and configuration.
Augmented employees directly adapt to the client’s organizational culture.
Third-party workers usually share a common language and cultural context with the client.
The augmented workforce adopts the client’s communication channels, protocols, and preferences.
Augmented staff members from overseas adjust to the client’s cultural and linguistic norms.
Cultural and communication dynamics
BPO companies establish and implement their own organizational culture.
Outsourcing deals involve cross-cultural collaboration as clients and providers originate from various cultural backgrounds and geographical areas.
Service vendors use centralized communication channels and protocols to ease interactions between their teams and clients.
BPO firms provide cultural awareness training to employees to promote diversity, inclusivity, and equality.
Because the client remains in charge of the project, the augmented workforce is less likely to produce inconsistent and low-quality output.
Service quality
Reliable service providers align work strategies with clients, resulting in high-quality outcomes.
Clients enforce data security measures, access controls, and confidentiality protection protocols.
The augmented workforce is subject to the client’s compliance policies and procedures, which vary based on industry rules and project requirements.
Security and compliance
BPO companies create and implement their own data security guidelines and controls.
Providers comply with industry-specific security and compliance standards such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
BPO contracts include security and compliance requirements that match legal and client regulations.
Staff augmentation vs. BPO: Which suits your business needs best?
Choosing between staff augmentation and BPO requires careful review and assessment of the abovementioned factors. The decision ultimately depends on your unique requirements and goals.
For instance, many businesses encounter skill gaps that impact their recruitment strategies and daily operations. According to Wiley’s 2023 research, 41% of companies hire temporary or contract employees to address the problem. Meanwhile, 34% outsource work to third parties.
So before striking a deal with augmented or BPO staff, weigh the pros and cons of each approach. Select short-term support that matches your urgent business needs during hectic seasons. Conversely, consider a long-term outsourcing engagement if your company aims to attain a steady, upward growth trajectory without overspending.
The bottom line
Regardless of the size of your company, the choice between staff augmentation and BPO depends on your specific requirements and business targets. You should also take note of the different factors that might impact your decisions and intended results.
Are you seeking temporary flexibility and specialized expertise without compromising direct control and output quality? Then, adopt staff augmentation. Or perhaps you need cost efficiency while optimizing a large talent pool in the long run. In that case, invest in BPO.
Picking one over the other is a matter of finding the right solution for your business at the right time. Whether you opt for staff augmentation, BPO, or a combination, look for a provider who understands your needs and fits your values. Hence, let’s connect today!
Joyce Ann Danieles is an SEO content writer from Manila, Philippines. She’s comfortable writing outsourcing-focused articles, helping you clarify the confusing concepts surrounding the BPO industry. With her experience in news writing and copywriting, she’s always ready to feed your brain with random facts and creative insights.
Outside work, Joyce explores the world of literature. She tries to write fiction she hopes to share with everyone someday.
Joyce Ann Danieles
We Build Your Next-Gen Team for a Fraction of the Cost. Get in Touch to Learn How.
Chicago companies can thrive by leveraging call center technology trends. This article explores emerging innovations, their role in enhancing customer service & how outsourcing to third-party call centers helps businesses meet evolving expectations & boost operational efficiency.
Effective BPO contract negotiation is key for Chicago businesses. This guide covers tips on legal compliance, exit strategies, and contingency plans to secure favorable terms and successful outsourcing partnerships. Learn more about Chicago’s business and legal landscape.
Scheduling inefficiencies, admin tasks, and communication breakdowns can disrupt healthcare and patient care. A virtual medical assistant (VMA) streamlines workflows, reduces errors, and enhances communication, improving clinic operations and patient satisfaction.
