Table of Contents
Navigating the ever-evolving workforce landscape can be challenging for business owners and human resources (HR) professionals. Thus, many rely on staffing agencies and employer of record (EOR) services to streamline workforce management.
While both options offer valuable and cost-saving solutions, their functionalities and legal implications differ significantly. Understanding their distinctions is critical to maximizing their benefits, maintaining control, minimizing risks, and reducing costs.
If you want to learn more about EOR and staffing agencies, this article is for you. Continue reading to understand their key differences and gain tips for more informed decision-making.
Roles and benefits of EOR providers and staffing agencies
Before discussing the differences between working with an EOR and a staffing agency, you must first understand their nature and objectives. Generally, both practices involve a third party taking over a significant portion of your HR and administrative tasks, including hiring and data entry services.
However, an EOR takes over the entire employer relationship, while a staffing agency focuses on finding and placing talent.
Below, we discuss the unique roles and benefits of EORs and staffing agencies.
What is an EOR?
A type of business process outsourcing (BPO), EOR services entail an external vendor acting as your workers’ legal employer. The third party is responsible for all HR tasks, including:
- Payroll processing
- Tax withholding and remittance
- Benefits administration
- Regulatory compliance
The practice has become widespread since the pandemic due to its ability to streamline remote workforce management, especially for global teams. According to the Valuates Report, the global EOR market reached $4.29 billion in 2023 and could grow to $6.6 billion in 2030.
Here are the primary benefits of partnering with an EOR firm:
- Increased focus on employer responsibilities. EOR teams know industry best practices and possess the skills to raise your ongoing employment life cycle to a high standard. They give you more time and energy to focus on core business activities.
- Reduced employer risks. You can gain peace of mind knowing specialists handle legal and financial employment liabilities. An EOR manages unemployment claims, workers’ compensation, wrongful termination lawsuits, and discrimination claims.
- Efficient international expansion. Hiring talent abroad often involves complex legal and compliance hurdles. The EOR complies with these laws so that you can easily hire workers. It lets you navigate the legal and regulatory landscape of new markets even without established agencies.
- Improved scalability. If your business needs fluctuate, you can easily adjust your workforce with the EOR provider’s help. It can connect you to more talent should you need to scale up. Conversely, it handles the complexities of employment termination if you are scaling down.
- Long-term solutions. The EOR’s legal and compliant employment framework creates a more secure and predictable work environment. It reduces employee turnover and costs associated with hiring talent.
What is a staffing agency?
Compared to an EOR, a staffing agency only acts as a bridge between your business and qualified candidates. Companies looking for temporary, contractual, or project-based hires often seek the assistance and expertise of these firms.
According to Insight Partners, the global staffing and recruitment market’s value reached $683 billion in 2022 and could grow by 12.7% by 2030.
Businesses continue to rely on staffing agencies because of the following benefits:
- Increased focus on talent acquisition. Staffing agencies build and maintain a pool of potential candidates through various channels, including online job boards, industry associations, professional events, and candidate databases.
- Enhanced access to specialized talent. As experts in specific industries or roles, staffing agencies can match candidates with your unique needs, helping you fill specialized positions quickly.
- Flexible talent solutions. Staffing agencies allow you to easily adjust your staffing levels based on project needs or seasonal fluctuations. You can hire workers to fill gaps or manage workload spikes without adding to your permanent headcount.
- Reduced cost for temporary needs. Using a staffing agency for temporary workers can be more cost-effective than hiring directly and handling all the administrative tasks yourself.
How to choose between an EOR and a staffing agency
Choosing between an EOR and a recruitment company to handle staffing needs requires careful consideration. You must factor in your company’s requirements, workforce strategy, and the legal complexities of international employment.
Here are some tips to help you decide between an EOR and a staffing agency:
1. Assess your business needs
Analyze your current workforce composition. Are you looking for long-term employees, temporary project workers, or a mix of both? EOR services are ideal for permanent positions, while staffing agencies are better at helping you fill short-term roles.
Compare the costs associated with EOR services and staffing agency fees. These include payroll taxes, benefits administration costs, and potential legal liabilities. This step helps you find a workforce management solution that best fits your needs.
2. Evaluate your HR strategy and capabilities
Assess your current resources for managing a workforce, from talent acquisition and onboarding to payroll processing and tax remittance. Define your priorities regarding time constraints, control, and flexibility. Consider how you will administer the employee benefits you plan to provide.
Ask these questions to help you choose between an EOR and a staffing agency based on your resources:
- Do you have the expertise to source qualified talent in specific industries or locations?
- How quickly do you need to hire new employees internationally?
- How much control do you want over the initial selection process?
- How involved do you want to be in day-to-day management and performance reviews?
- Do you prioritize the flexibility to scale your workforce up and down based on project needs?
- Will you offer employee benefits such as health insurance or retirement plans?
3. Consider legal implications of international employment
If you plan to employ a global remote team, you must research the complexities of labor and tax laws in your target areas. Understanding the legal liabilities of hiring foreign talent helps you decide if you need specialized expertise.
Additionally, consider your timeline for international expansion. How quickly do you need to hire new employees internationally? Setting up a legal agency in a different country can be time-consuming. An EOR is well-versed in navigating tax and labor laws in various jurisdictions, helping you expedite the entire process.
Evaluating the differences between EOR providers and staffing agencies
As with managed information technology (IT) services and IT support outsourcing, EOR services and recruitment agencies differ significantly.
The table below can help you understand these solutions’ unique features and weigh each factor based on your priorities and capabilities.
| Factor | EOR firm | Staffing agency |
|---|---|---|
| Legal compliance and responsibilities | The EOR assumes the full legal responsibility of an employer, protecting your business from legal and financial risks. | Staffing agencies are intermediaries between you and the scouted talent but do not assume legal responsibility. |
| Scope of services | Service vendors cover various HR tasks, including payroll, tax, benefits, and compliance administration. They can handle onboarding and international employment setups. | Recruitment firms focus on sourcing, screening, and placing qualified candidates. Although they might offer onboarding assistance, they have limited management involvement. |
| Employment relationship | With EOR services, your company remains the direct employer. Workers only report to the EOR for administrative matters, such as payroll and benefits. | With staffing agencies, workers are not considered hired under your business. The employee’s contract is with the recruitment company, not with yours. |
| Control over workforce | In EOR partnerships, you retain high control and involvement in selecting and hiring candidates. For daily tasks, employees still report to your company’s management team. | In a partnership with a staffing agency, you have less control over the entire recruitment process. However, you are still responsible for the temporary talent’s work performance. |
| Ideal employment duration | Partnering with an EOR is ideal for long-term or permanent employment. It offers stability, scalability, and structure for your business and its employees. | Working with a recruitment agency offers flexibility for fluctuating staffing needs. Thus, it is ideal for filling short-term positions, whether seasonal or contractual. |
| International expansion | EOR teams are trained to navigate the complexities of international tax and labor regulations. They have global agencies, eliminating your need to establish one. | Unlike EOR teams, staffing agencies do not assume an employer’s full legal responsibilities. Your company can still face legal exposure in global employment. |
The bottom line
Which one should you choose, an EOR or a staffing agency? Both offer many benefits that allow businesses to streamline workforce management. However, these two practices differ significantly in terms of service scope, employment relationship, duration, and global capabilities.
An EOR covers all aspects of HR processes, including regulatory compliance. It is ideal for long-term and international employment. On the other hand, staffing companies act as a separate employer from your business. They specialize in sourcing and recruiting candidates for short-term positions.
When deciding between the two practices, aligning your choice with your business goals and workforce requirements is crucial. Let’s connect if you want to learn more about EOR services.
